One doesn't need horizontal volumes to trade VSA, I don't think such thing even existed when Tom Williams wrote his book. VSA is not only about "volume imbalance of bars", it's about everything. LRA should be compared with Wyckoff's work, because ...

VSA (Volume Spread Analysis) vs LRA (Locked-in Range Analysis)

up

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge

up

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge

Is there any way to add a button on the chart for the "Hide_All", to be easier to switch it on or off?

Fixing Your Indicators or EAs (Free)

Is there any way to add a button on the chart for the "Hide_All", to be easier to switch it on or off?

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge

this my sound random, but anyone interested in creating a telegram group for active traders, so we can share setups real time? if so pm me.

vsa with Malcolm

I would agree with this, only thing ar should be on smaller volume imo

vsa with Malcolm

yes, volumes are vital for us, I've tried switching to ctrader platform on fxpro for lower spreads but the volumes a garbage there, I was thinking on pepperstone... but I will check fxcm also....

vsa with Malcolm

good point! fxpro I've just compared with yours, looks the same.

vsa with Malcolm

this is what I saw

vsa with Malcolm

That's exactly how I manage my swings, I set big targets but as soon as I seen something I don't like I take the profit and say thanks )), as you said it, no point of making a winning trade a loosing one. Also with BE stuff and risk free I ...

vsa with Malcolm

This one went fast, was hoping for another leg down to get a better entry, but NS appeared after the break of AR and I took the entry. After that I saw the closing of 1h bar, increase in volume but no wick, strong up close and I decided to hold ...

vsa with Malcolm

Nice, what risk reward are you aiming for, or it all depends on each trade, levels, and so on. Judging from my today's trades, which of course is too soon, I can see a "guaranteed" reward of 1R, this is not much, especially after my swing trades (7R ...

vsa with Malcolm

yes I agree, the volume wasn't very high but when I saw that 5m volume on the highest point I decided to take it, tho I was out early, well it was my first trade on m5 so I wasn't very sure ))

vsa with Malcolm

same as previous

vsa with Malcolm

A simple setup I took today, but closed too soon tho. Downtrend, retracement to 50% fibo, climatic volume confirmed on m5, ND.

vsa with Malcolm

I found this guy Peter Fader, I'm sure many heard him, he's trading on m5 timeframe. I found that in his course he basically covers all this stuff you mentioned, his setups looks very similar with yours.

vsa with Malcolm

A question for those trading intraday. Because of the fact that in my swing trading strategy, the setups don't appear so often and I have a lot of free time between them, I'm looking to build a high probability intraday strategy aiming for 1-2R, in ...

vsa with Malcolm

why you need it for then?

vsa with Malcolm

Is tradeguider software available free for mt4? I see a lot of discussion about it in this thread...

vsa with Malcolm