Hi, malcolmb, Could you tell me why you change to M30 chart from M15? I am not sure but wonder if you see a M15 chart at that time, the hull maybe is red. Thanks in advance.

vsa with Malcolm

MT5 — It doesn't matter, friend. BTW, justnow I found ibfx provides mt5 for testing. I installed it successfully but failed to open a demo account. I dont know whether it is due to the close market. What makes me interested in it is MT5 can ...

vsa with Malcolm

bruceli, thanks for your infomation. Since brokers use different daily session open time, IMHO the daily chart is less important that other smaller timeframe charts. Moreover, VSAers tend to use M15/M5 chart to make an entry/exit decision, so if you ...

vsa with Malcolm

Hello guys, I have attached gbp/usd m15 charts from three brokers, fxdd, fxsol and ibfx. All of them are live account. I think fxdd is more reliable when we are talking that abnormal volume spike in last early europe session. What do you think? have ...

vsa with Malcolm

Malcolm, Thank you very much. You are always the best.

vsa with Malcolm

Here you go. It works but not be optimized.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

need your help — Could anybody post an eur/usd M15 chart with volumes? I prefer a chart from esignal feed. Thanks in advance.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

eur/usd marks up during asian session, after Frankfurt Open and London Open, the volume is relative low compared with past sessions. Does it mean BB are not intrested in higher price?

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hope not spoil this VSA thread.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

As per someone's request, I'd like to post a tool to do this, since I cannot attache that via private message.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hello, could you explain how to predict the volume? by average of the same session during the past days, or by average of previous N bars? polomine

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Thank you very much, f451. I am still wondering why there are differences between the top and the bottom in forex market. Since we are trading the currency pair, selling one equals buying the other. regards, polomine

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

good points, thank you. I found myself a little over trading, Could you tell me how many trades you make everyday upon the current market condition?

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Thank you. I missed the long opportunity and now waiting for short.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hello, Do you mean the professional intend to find a good position to sell?

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

in this case, what does it confirm? IMHO, ND acts as a confirmation of weak background, ie. buying climax, upthrust. Maybe I should not have ignored the impact of non farm data and kept away from the market.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

IMHO, ND should appear at the top of an up trend. Since the trend is down, we should not expect a ND. The low vol bar close high, it seems to test supply. Any feedback would be appreciated.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hello everyone, Hope you have many pips gained today. Please see the chart, if you had short eur/usd, would you exit or long when you see the low vol test after climax bar? Thanks polomine

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Thank you! If I am not wrong, you get it from the following link: url But I think it is older than this one: url I am not sure because the latter isn't source codes. Regards, polomine

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hi, The lastest version of HGV indicator I can find in this thread is V4 . url Please tell me where I can get the V5 . Thanks polomine

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)