No, this is not a re-post. I've said these things before, but you continue to ignore them for some reason. I don't like all the indicators on your chart, but you do you. But it appears like you have at least two MAs on the chart. The purple one is ...

vsa with Malcolm

I refrained from answering this post, but those who did pretty much nailed it. ISSUE #1: You've heard this a million times, and you will hear it a million more- the 1M timeframe is not an ideal timeframe to try to trade !!!! The M1 by its very ...

vsa with Malcolm

You don't have to ask. All are welcome here. We do not all trade the same way, but we are all Volume Spread Analysis (VSA) traders. Post away.

vsa with Malcolm

The simple, although not entirely complete, answer is that price can be arbitraged and volume can not. Ex. Broker A 1 Euro = 3 Dollars. Broker B. 1 Euro = 6 Dollars. An arbitrageur would buy Euros from Broker A and then sell them to Broker B ...

It's Unreliable

I would indeed call that No Supply. But then something very strange happens................ The Market changes its mind !!!! Okay, it's not that strange. It happens all the time. The Market changes its mind as new information comes in. The fact that ...

vsa with Malcolm

Wow. Such honesty and wisdom in this post. There's a lot to unpack here, and to be honest myself, I think most of it has to do with trader psychology and not trading methodology (i.e. Volume Spread Analysis ((VSA))). I'm not going to say much on the ...

vsa with Malcolm

I'm just going to say this: If you put indicators on your chart you should NEVER trade against them. If you want to trade against them, what's the point in having them on the chart in the first place? You either want to catch tops or bottoms or you ...

vsa with Malcolm

Please post a chart and answer this: Why are you trying to go long after seeing a Buying Climax and an Up Trust? These are signs of weakness. They tell you that the Smart Money is Selling. After the Buying Climax, you should be looking for the ...

vsa with Malcolm

This is a great example of my personal frustration with Gavin. He claims to be a trend trader but often takes trades against the trend. Especially, during a LIVE webinar (again, this is because he is trying to sell software and make "winning" trades ...

vsa with Malcolm

Gavin maintains that both indicators use volume and that neither one is, or employs, a "moving average". I don't believe him, and Gregory once said that the Medium Term Indicator does use a "moving average". Trying to determine exactly what TG ...

vsa with Malcolm

This is probably going to be a really long post. I may have to break it up into two posts. I debated whether or not to post this at all, but we are all here to learn and grow together. The only guarantee in trading is that you will have losing ...

vsa with Malcolm

Great work. For what it's worth, I'm taking a loss on this chart too. image As to be expected, I have added HB to the Tigger Number Matrix. This is a very important level for me. Not only did Wyckoff talk about HB, but in a recent TG webinar, ...

vsa with Malcolm

It's a clear Test (failed) on yours too. But let's back up for a minute. As I have stated numerous times, I believe that VZA is nothing more than a distinction without a difference. That's. not what this post is really about, but I thought it needed ...

vsa with Malcolm

image I have added a full (although crude) trigger matrix to the chart. It strikes me as a great time to respond to a couple of things brought up in some recent posts. I am not an expert. I am learning Volume Spread Analysis (VSA) just like ...

vsa with Malcolm

I've never heard that before. Well, that's not an issue in my case. What I was going to point out is that there is no volume on the chart.

vsa with Malcolm

I believe that is precisely why Gavin staged a coup and ousted Todd. Todd wanted to focus on trading and Gavin wanted to sell software.

vsa with Malcolm

While a few VSA traders will wait to see if the second bar after a test is UP (assuming the previous bar is DOWN), most. VSA traders consider a test confirmed or unconfirmed based solely on the first (i.e. next) bar. Accordingly, there is only 1 bar ...

vsa with Malcolm

Slow your roll. You have access to one of the most successful Volume Spread Analysis (VSA) traders on the planet. He's giving you the key to the kingdom. Be grateful and show the respect he is due. You are absolutely correct that there is a ...

vsa with Malcolm

While it is a core concept in VSA that professional money (Smart Money) oporates on all timeframes, as a retail trader using VSA, recent tradeguider videos not withstanding, it almost certainly behooves you to trade HIGHER TIME FRAMES. I could be, ...

vsa with Malcolm

I use Sierra Chart and it is not currently available for MAC. I think you can use "parallels" but I would prefer not to do that.

vsa with Malcolm