ok ill read those frank...thanks again...regards,john

vsa with Malcolm

frankkn — frank ive been watching the blue supply/demand boxes you post ans they seem to be quite accurate...how again do you determine your blue boxe areas???best regards, john...good work btw

vsa with Malcolm

tradeguider software — been seriously considering purchasing the full version of tradeguider software...was wondering are there any newbies here who have the software and are actually making money with it???? ive watched alot of videos with ...

vsa with Malcolm

have to agree with msmarple..pres78 (along with all the gang here) has really helped me out on learning VSA...dont want to see any body go!! hope you reconsider pres..best regards, john

vsa with Malcolm

excercise — ive posted a chart of the current EU 1h chart..i placed arrows(that correspond with the vol) and labeled them..(stole this idea from belikewater!) below are my answers...any response from the grooup is much appreciated...best ...

vsa with Malcolm

hidden gap — excellent video on youtube with gavin..HG appreciate the heads up!..the coolest thing is gavin had absolutely no DD on that trade and was 100% confident as to its outcome!!! thats got to be a great feeling!!! i wonder if he ever ...

vsa with Malcolm

pres78 — heres the daily of that same chart with the channel you mentioned...the trendlines and words are tom williams, not mine!(MA's are mine) its his newsletter chart...using your channel and his trendlines(and even the 50ema, for me) was a ...

vsa with Malcolm

pres78 — sorry pres78..was watching VSA club videos!LOL...great explanation ..no i did not notice this without you pointing it out...but i do see exactly what your saying...great observation... im going to study this chart and what youve ...

vsa with Malcolm

question — since things have slowed abit...would someone mind telling me if the highlighted area is a "two Bar reversal" or does the volume need to be higher?..thanks in advance///regards, john

vsa with Malcolm

looking at the eu 15m i can see that each of the up bars has alot volume behind them and each of the down either have low volume of high vol but then dont go any where and are followed by a higher volume up bar...all signs of strength.at least on ...

vsa with Malcolm

intel — you see after you put it that way i see that... i dont know why im always looking to catch the topp of a turn...i will watch an entire move up just trying to guess the turn...LOL....and it never works!!! really gotta reprogram my ...

vsa with Malcolm

got it franksa...thanks!!! regards, john

vsa with Malcolm

Intel — ok thank you intel...not really trading this as i just dont have the experience in vsa yet...but im trying to shape my thinking in the right direction...best regards, john

vsa with Malcolm

EU 30m upthrust??? but you need to see more than just an upthrust right?..weakness in the background and maybe a ND, next, would be more favorable...and some form of sow on a larger TF would be even better...does this sound correct? please ...

vsa with Malcolm

belikewater — my 2 cents; A/B) selling climax, SOS c) test..Failed due to volume to high D) test ...back into the previous high volume area...passed on account volume is lower than at point C price moves up from there.... thats what my take is ...

vsa with Malcolm

Kinsalefx — OH SH#T!!!! i am so sorry liam....i just realised that!!! dude i totally apololgize!!! maybe thats why im so bad at VSA ..my powers of observation arent very obvious sometimes..LOL...it was not intentional brother...again my ...

vsa with Malcolm

much thanks — thanks liam and pres78 for looking at the chart i posted...by reading your post im gonna say i sorta kinda was on the right track....i didnt notice that it was the highest volume of the last 3 days...great eye pres78...but i was ...

vsa with Malcolm

kinforsale — hey thats great to hear kinforsale...you guys are all real good about trying to help someone learn..its appreciated!!! would you mind looking at the ej daily i just posted and sharing your thoughts..much obliged, TX (sorry about ...

vsa with Malcolm

TEST??? — i know some you dont care for the yen crosses but would you say this is a good example of a "test" on the E/J Daily??? we have a wide spread/ low volume closing (well , we have 3 hrs left to close)on the higher end of the candle that ...

vsa with Malcolm

belikewater — that was a great exercise ...thank you for sharing it!!! TX

vsa with Malcolm