Hello everybody! Will you help me with bar 1? At first I saw price go up on low vol, then bar 1 appeared and I decided that market not ready to go down yet. It is inside bar and it's confusing me. Thank you!

vsa with Malcolm

I don't know, in the main I cant see any considerable difference. And I use also 20.

vsa with Malcolm

Yes, I see... Thank you!

vsa with Malcolm

Whu the second bar failed to confirm bying? The second bar is an up bar closing on the high with high volume. May be it was failed test which showed us that supply presents?

vsa with Malcolm

You mean the following bar on your chart is something like a squat? I thought you telling about this bar B. Which shows that there is supply.

vsa with Malcolm

Yes, it was USD GDP release.

vsa with Malcolm

From the one hand bar A is a sign of streangth. We see a lower low with high (ultra high volume) closing up. What strange here is ultra high volume! From the other hand we see up bar closing on the high with ULTRA high volume, so supply can be ...

vsa with Malcolm

Will you close your position because of the very high vol on 1H? Thanks!

vsa with Malcolm

In what trade Intel? Long Short? I cant decide where wi will go...

vsa with Malcolm

Exited out at 1.2751 and took 73 pips from the table!

vsa with Malcolm

Entered on bad news for EUR. Bar 1 closed off the low and on a huge volume. Selling climax.

vsa with Malcolm

Thank you for your advice! Now I'm going to sleep! Good trading to you Malcolmb and to everyone!!!

vsa with Malcolm

Thank you for your answer!!! Well, yes! 4H chart is not very good for VSA! But I decided to trade on higher timeframes for better results... 1D is too high timeframe....1H - may be better, but I can't stay near PC all the time... so I thought to ...

vsa with Malcolm

Hello! Please, need yor help! The last bar: Is it NS bar? bar 1 is higher high bar. May be it must be read as ND bar??? I know that ND is an up bar with vol lower then previous 2. But this bar went higher than previous bar, thats why I am confused! ...

vsa with Malcolm

Yeah!!! lol

vsa with Malcolm

Hello, malcolmb14! Do you consider that GU now in the top of the daily channel and it can be overbought? I see in my picture some signs of weak market.... Some kind of top reversal (4H chart)... And also we are in old top market area (D chart). And ...

vsa with Malcolm

Yes, I know that ND and NS is opposite thing, but what about a test for a bull force?

vsa with Malcolm

Hi! Why SM can't do the same thing in a bear market like "a test" in bull market? Or they do it in form of ND? Thanks!!!

vsa with Malcolm

Thank You very much for a such huge and very informative post!!!!!! So, maybe I'm not so bad student.... Am I right? Is this bar a "Test bar"? Or it is not, because of the next bar is down?

vsa with Malcolm

Hello, HiddenGap!!! Will you be so kind to explain me why "Test (KRB)" on your chart is sign of strength? For me there is no buying force.... like a "ND"! Please, help! Thank You!!!

vsa with Malcolm