This thread exploded today.. I just wanted to comment on the 1h chart. We did see supply today.. but what seems odd to me is that price is not being held up its steadily drifting down. I think our old friend 3025 is going to be the key ...

vsa with Malcolm

I have not been able to replicate your 12h charts.. I have tried using LO and US start times, you have a nice HV UT right at the top of yours that I do not. Still bullish, I think that Friday was a SO, and looking for some testing at the start of ...

vsa with Malcolm

4h EU chart. Between Thursday and Friday we have quite a bit of volume come in, in the last leg up from 12/3-12/5 we see supply coming into the market, its not uncommon especially on down moves to see a quick widespread down bar on ultra high volume ...

vsa with Malcolm

Direct link to MTM: url Yes, MTM is an introductory book, even on the first couple of pages it tells you the purpose of the book is to teach you "the basic introductory principles of VSA methodology". MTM teaches you the foundation of VSA so you ...

vsa with Malcolm

I understand and I know you do not want to start a debate. All I ask is that you think about this and keep an open mind and I will agree to end this discussion here in this posting. url If Dark Liquidity, which omits volume from the public, and in ...

james16 Chart Thread

Interesting opinion you have there. Its not about the indicator is about the broker feed, volume will differ from broker to broker, but honestly as long as you have one of the larger and reputable brokers it will work just fine.

james16 Chart Thread

Perhaps you did not want to short into support.

vsa with Malcolm

I think you are getting hung up on the wrong details.. Lets say you buy 1 lot, price goes up and you sell it for a profit. I come in and buy your lot, for one thing you do not know how long I am I planning on holding on to your lot.. could be a few ...

james16 Chart Thread

Here is a couple, I couldnt remember if you use sierra so just in case if you do..

vsa with Malcolm

But honestly for someone new to VSA I think that your trade is a bit risky, referring back to my post about only trading a SC/BC, SO/UT and NS/ND. Here is what I see as an easy traditional VSA trade. First bar is a BC Second a HV UT Third is a LV UT ...

vsa with Malcolm

heh, you an Intel have the back and forth going on! Lets start with your 1 bar, you labeled Selling Climax, look at the volume on this bar, and look at the volume on the bar before. The volume is high, but not climatic. Now look at bar 9, the volume ...

vsa with Malcolm

@13:17. Do not trust those people on the forums teaching VSA. I bet he was referring to this thread! Thanks for the video. Excellent post!

vsa with Malcolm

Yes, if you only traded these two setups you would do well. Buying Climax, up thrust and no demand at resistance. Selling Climax, reverse up thrust and no supply at support.

vsa with Malcolm

That is a hard question to answer with out a chart. Lets say in you have a strong background (SC, SO and a test) as a result price rises and pushes through support, then price comes back down to the support it just pushed through and tests with low ...

vsa with Malcolm

You chart is starting to take form. Four bars back, the bar marked 9 by HG, that widespread up bar was gaped up from the bar before, which we know gap ups are usually weak. Combine the very wide spread, the gap up and the ultra high volume it is ...

vsa with Malcolm

Yes its a 23k post thread, but look at the dates of the posts.. You may notice that it is not really that active. The better volume "indi" you are only using it for volume, since volume does not change, there are no settings to change. Better volume ...

vsa with Malcolm

Nice post, you are good at getting people to think. This goes hand and hand with your test question. You do well with your bar by bar analysis. I however get confused, so I try to do my best at keeping it simple as possible (maybe I even make it too ...

vsa with Malcolm

If he posts, they will come! Stopping volume marked in yellow. In red we saw some supply. (I personally did not expect there to be enough to break the low of the channel.) Orange more stopping volume. Green Test Blue supply from last Friday. We ...

vsa with Malcolm

Nice call!

vsa with Malcolm

Interesting Sono is bearish on DX and Tao bearish on EU. 4h EU, may have some stopping volume today.

vsa with Malcolm