again period_converter — OK, first of all the two others period_converters that I've downloaded are Indicators (not scripts), and should go into the Indicators' folder; I've tried one of them, and everything seems fine with the volume (no ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

warning - period_converter — Just wanted to leave a warning to those using period_converter in order to get smaller TF charts, that it seems to have a problem calculating volume for the new chart; In fact, using the original script from ibfx ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Those sentences can be perfectly applied to someone who bans an expert (to everybody's eyes), after he simply disagreed on a called trade; and to someone who immediately removes the post where he called the wrong trade (trying to erase evidence). ...

Learn to Trade using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

WG, you're right (I think Obaidah didn't mean to say that and made some confusion with words maybe); A shake-out is seen in bottoms before reversing - it's the equivalent to the upthrust in tops, so it's also called a reversed upthrust - and it ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

In the lack of "professional" responses, let me tell you that I think you're focusing in the wrong points. Some considerations of my own (pros can come and correct me later): - Don't pay too much attention to the news itself... it will be reflected ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Well, by watching both comparisons, I would say they are generally the same (very little differences); The little difference in the colour of 1 bar, I think, can also be caused by differences in the spread, because that's better volume indi, which ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Yes of course, what matters is to have dimensional relation between bars as similar as possible to esignal; The numbers don't matter... curiously, when I loaded an ibfx chart to use it for charting, I was counting on finding bigger volume numbers ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Grath, I believe some use one and some the other... I, for instance, use only CDRW volume - the relation to price, I make it mentally (requires learning the different meanings); As for the colours in bars, it isn't absolute quantity, but relative ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

What megamo tells us is worth being clarified... I have a live account with Alpari UK, but was planning on maybe using ibfx's demo for the charting, due to the "closest to esignal" volume feed; But now I'm wondering if that visual comparison was ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

That's what I think... If I may add, I don't even use the better volume indi, at least for now; I feel a lot more confident using CDRW Volume (which colours the volume according to if it's bigger/smaller/between last 2 volume bars). The point with ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

By the way, Mal, Islander, Shamus and others: I've been lurking in the chatroom several times, as a guest (vsa_something), learning a lot from all of you Starting next week, and during at least 2 weeks, I will be trading fulltime during ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hi Mal, The questions weren't about the better volume indi; It's about the "volume histogram" indi, by Forex Flash, which ShamusFamous added now to the first page. It's an indi which colours the volume in 3 different colours, to show ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I ask the same question; But anyway, I noticed it repaints... when the current volume and bar are changing, all the volumes behind keep changing size and colours... so I wonder what would be the appropriate way to read it, if it still can be used. ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

See if this fits:

Slingshot 30M & 1H - The 2nd Coming......

Exactly. My heads up was specially to Steveg, as from his words I got the impression he would rely on it too much, and was maybe unaware of the cons. Toni. Edit: Yes Steve, data integrity. With bad or incomplete data, ST can take or ...

Slingshot 30M & 1H - The 2nd Coming......

I wouldn't believe it to be possible... until I found this thread, and saw the account's statements I read all the thread last month, read and re-read the pdf doc, checked the chat room a few times, and started trading it... And guess what? I ...

Learn to Trade using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hi guys, keep up the good work. Just wanted to make a "heads up" concerning the use of the Strategy tester, since you don't seem to be aware of that (sorry if I'm wrong): First of all, it isn't very reliable; But for it to be more reliable, you have ...

Slingshot 30M & 1H - The 2nd Coming......

Hi all, and congrats to the great job you're all making here. I'm quietly following it, and haven't bumped in before because of the lack of time presently to join in and participate. You might want to take into account the hard coded slipage, when a ...

Slingshot 30M & 1H - The 2nd Coming......

Kristo, I suppose you did that to protect the profit, as the bar was so long? (I'm asking because it was a setup bar anyway, so by the rules, we had a place to put the SL). Guys, I was away all weekend. But anyway, I will be less around, at least ...

4H 5EMA System

Hi Sean, I've mixed up the contexts, as you pointed out: First I spoke about a reversal bar (but still in trade)... then I was speaking about a reversal bar stopped before close (being flat at its end)! Not making sense, clearly But then you got ...

4H 5EMA System