how do u know which direction

NanningBob Study Club

astral — how interesting..... hmmmm..... it's very new to me. i read it. and downloaded it.... hmmm. it seems to me, this renko idea.... you will be taking, very, very few trades. do u think it best we just keep trading bob's system and wait ...

NanningBob Study Club

usd/jpy trade — yes. i am still in it. i took this trade with the macd not at the bottom. i regretted taking the trade.... but now.....it's almost 200 pips in profit. do u think i should have taken this trade? after i took it, it kept going ...

NanningBob Study Club

astral — no...quite new to forex, not new to trading in general though. any comments and opinions from you is very much appreciated. any judgements too. we are all here cuz we want to make money. my biggest weakness is the gambling mentality. ...

NanningBob Study Club

macd — i've noticed the darn macd changes position too... how do we know where it really was at, in real time in the past when we backtest?

NanningBob Study Club

phanti — phanti, you made a good call on this trade, because you called long and went long, not because you predicted a BB squeeze would result in a spike, as that is inevitable. we all know the bb squeeze will eventually mean a burst in ...

NanningBob Study Club

blue — haha....now, if we were to believe in the test results of toothman, in theory, if we do a sell on the eur/usd at this moment..... it's an 80% win rate...... in theory. it'll probably happen. but how much is one to put in? 1 lot? 2? i ...

NanningBob Study Club

phanti — u made a good call. just because the bollinger bands were coming together? the link you posted here doesn't work.

NanningBob Study Club

. — blue, yes, i know, just getting more info, that's all. it's because i wasn't around from earlier versions...therefore, i am not sure if it was bad because there were so many runners to try to recover from; or if it was bad even if you took ...

NanningBob Study Club

astral — you may be right sir... i'm very new to using bob's system. i took a usdchf, H4 trade. if you look at the charts, you can see where i took it. and why i took it. i was hoping for a 100 sl/tp. right now, it's up +143 @ 1 full lot. if ...

NanningBob Study Club

sixths indicator — bob says you'll get killed when you trade in between the green lines. ofcourse...what is in the green lines, depends on the timeframe being used. so we have the 6th indicator. with hardset tp/sl in place... in the opinion of ...

NanningBob Study Club

just another crazy idea — for any of you guys, who have tried 1 minute trend scalping (like me).... you'll get killed using bob's system. we all know why. if 50 ppl try it, 50 will get killed. if 100 people try it, 100 will get killed. now, i ...

NanningBob Study Club

astral — sir......4000 dd.....that's......really a lot....

NanningBob Study Club

toothman — thanks for your work sir. in regards to the euraud being the best trending currency, and that eurcad,eurnzd,eurchf,gbpnzd,gbpchf,gbpaud,gbp/cad, all are bad for this system.... should we still fear them if the tp/sl is 100? what is ...

NanningBob Study Club

bluemele — thanks for your kind reply sir.

NanningBob Study Club

toothman — and if we did 100/100 on past years? i.e. the test you did for 100% win rate?

NanningBob Study Club

bluemele — hi blue, based on your observation, through all this time, on this system, if a trade goes +80, would you say it is more likely for it to go on to see an additional +80 before it went back to zero? (i.e. +160 and BE) same for any ...

NanningBob Study Club

phanti — dude.... it's almost like.... everything i type, you just say the complete opposite... funny thing is, you do it, coming across using a very agreeable attitude to what i am typing. even funnier is, a dumb ass like me, should be happy ...

NanningBob Study Club

toothman — what i mean is, you see a pretty good trade. you take it. it goes against you 100 pips. liquidate it. keep using the system on other currencies. 48 hours later, you notice the exact same currency, ran for another 300 pips. rules ...

NanningBob Study Club

toothman & backtesters — great that you guys agree with my view. now we all know, in reality, you aren't really going to wait out for these "perfect trades". also, if EA1 & EA2 entries are giving you good results, what about the bulge ...

NanningBob Study Club