Not exactly... from what I've read, there has been changes in the BV indicator... and so has changed the literature about it; At least in the latest change (which included that colour modification), there has been a change in the literature to ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

mima, BV uses the normal volume you get from the broker; its utility is only to paint the bars, in a way to assist you classifying those bars - but of course, if you have wrong volume, BV won't save you. About the 2 charts you've posted... I would ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Steve, I also use ibfx demo for charting, and trade on an Alpari UK live account. I brought the same doubt not long ago here in the thread: The thing is ibfx 5 digit demo is somehow screwed up, regarding volume; At that time, I installed a new demo ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I'm not sure, but I suppose what we can see in Malcolm's charts must be it (the coloured volume bars looks like it); He's the only one I remember to see posting esignal's charts here... send him a pm about it, or wait to see if someone else has it ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

To finish this analysis: I made a fresh ibfx demo installation on my desktop (downloaded a new setup file): Two demo servers were presented to choose from, one of which classified as 4 digit, "IBFX-MT4 Demo-2_4 decimal" - it all went well with this ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Well, that might just be it: The 5 digit demo is far off, while the 4 digit demo is similar. When I try a manual login, I get 2 servers from where to login from: - IBFX-MT4 Demo-1_5 decimal; - InterbankFX-Demo Accounts. I suppose the second one is ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Better view of what I meant here:

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Nice. Strange thing I noticed: I compared this chart with both my demo ibfx and live Alpari UK charts... and I now noticed the ibfx chart had nothing to do with it, while my live Alpari was very similar When I started, it used to be the ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

PipForceA, It's not like we invented the thing in this thread As I'm sure you know, vsa studies exists since a long time ago, and was named liked that back then. I think I remember that, on one of the trade guider's video, it was explained that ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I'm sorry, I can't help there because I don't use the CDRW indicators - all I use is the Better Volume Indicator. I draw S/R lines myself for reference on possible reaction areas. Try locating the posts where such indis were added, and see if the ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

PipForceA, for hints about entry signals, exit signals, etc, you would have to read the thread and the recommended books... how we trade is inside; As for money and risk management, those are variables depending on the trader - no one trades the ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I would particularly like to re-compare my volume and "regular" volume from other server in ibfx, against e-signal volume from Malcolm or someone else who has it... to see which is closer from it, now. Mal, If you read this, post a chart from a ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I brought this possibility in the chat too (that it could be something related to some servers only)... My server is InterbankFX-Demo Accounts (different than yours... I don't even have yours listed). I'm in europe, for what it's worth. To Redox77: ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Only have one gu to compare to mine, but it's obvious both in that one as in the other pairs, that something changed at ibfx, because volumes are huge, comparing to before My real Alpari account has no changes... all volumes are the same ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Guilty from reporting that in the chat...lol So let me be the first one, so the others can compare it to mine. This one is gu 1H... notice the huge volume these last couple of days... more than doubled or tripled the usual volume. It's visible on ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I think Mal uses the same feed as you. The point is not the quantity of volume - the numbers don't matter; What matters is the size relation between bars, and it's in that sense that Ibfx is considered to be good.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hello Steve, First of all I want to congratulate you for the great EA, which I'm beginning to use now, essencially to manage my exits with jumping stop and partial closures (the hardest part to respect for me), as well as for adding missing stops ...

Multi-purpose trade management EA

OK taomql4, But you said it all in this sentence: I've seem spectacular EAs on trending market, and fantastic ones on ranging market... but I haven't seen any doing good work on both, meaning generally, those who win on one, loose on the other... or ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I tend to agree with Grath and think there's a space for both thread and chat. I've followed the thread since its beginning, as well as NYSE's thread before that... and think everything you need to learn is already in here. If one reads the all ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I agree, Mal... keep it simple guys, study and practise it!

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)